Brain Tumor Treatment Breakthrough!February 2014
By William Faloon and Lisa Antone
CMV: The Cancer Connection
Over the past decade, scientists have become increasingly concerned at the growing association of CMV with certain cancers. While it is too early to label CMV a true cancer-causing virus,22 evidence implicating CMV as a contributor to cancer comes from several observations:
- Studies show a strong correlation between cancer incidence and the percentage of adults who test positive for CMV.23,24
- CMV proteins and DNA have been found in 90-100% of malignant cells from a variety of cancers, especially those of the brain, breast, prostate, liver, lung, and colon.1,25-33
- CMV genes, once inserted into the host’s own DNA, increase inflammation-generating genes that promote cancer growth.34,35
- CMV genes are known to induce mutations in host tumor-suppressor genes, increasing the risk that a new cancer will develop.36
- CMV may help cancer cells avoid detection by the immune system by several mechanisms including increased secretion of immune suppressive cytokines.22
- CMV-infected cells produce more of the growth factors and chemical receptors needed for tumor development and invasion, compared to non-infected cells.32,33,37
The evidence for a direct connection between CMV and malignancy is by far the greatest in the case of the deadly brain tumor called glioblastoma multiforme (often simply “glioblastoma”). This tumor is the most common and aggressive brain cancer, and it carries a dismal prognosis.38,39
Most patients die within the first 15 months of diagnosis, with few surviving past 3 years.40-42
Glioblastomas occur most commonly in the frontal and temporal (side) lobes of the brain, where they produce disturbing symptoms that include persistent headaches, double or blurred vision, vomiting, changes in mood and personality, changes in cognition, seizures, and speech difficulty.42
In addition to their aggressive growth, glioblastomas are notoriously difficult to treat because of their location within the brain, where efforts to extract them are complicated by their deep invasion of healthy brain tissue and the brain’s limited ability to repair itself.40,42 Patients with glioblastomas frequently experience a number of clinical complications including seizures, blood clots, fluctuating neurological symptoms as well as side effects from powerful corticosteroids and chemotherapeutic drugs.43
Glioblastomas leak fluid, increasing the pressure on brain tissue; they also disrupt the blood supply, making it difficult for anti-cancer drugs to reach them.42
All of this accounts for the fact that, despite three decades of research, we have managed to increase overall survival in cases of glioblastoma by only about 3 months.42,44 Making matters worse, the tumor strikes at the prime of life, occurring mainly in adults between 45 and 70, with a median age at death of 64 years.42
The high incidence of glioblastoma, coupled with the difficulty of its treatment, has made the search for causes and preventive measures paramount. That’s why this emerging evidence about the link between CMV and malignant brain tumors is exciting to so many researchers.34
Strong Link Between CMV And Brain Cancer
There are a number of lines of evidence closely linking CMV with glioblastomas specifically, as well as to cancer in general. Virtually all glioblastomas have been found to contain CMV particles, proteins, and DNA (in one study of 250 patients, only one was CMV-negative).1,2,45 In fact, the amount of CMV in a glioblastoma is closely correlated with the tumor stage: More advanced tumors contain more CMV.22 Recent studies show that the amount of CMV in a tumor can accurately predict survival time in glioblastoma victims, with those carrying the most virus dying significantly earlier (average 13 months) than those with lower viral burden (average 33 months).45,46
Ironically, and tragically, further evidence of CMV involvement in glioblastoma comes from treatment misadventures with the cancer chemotherapy drug temozolomide. This drug, one of the few approved for treating glioblastoma, is powerfully immunosuppressive.47 In glioblastoma patients being treated with temozolomide, reports are now appearing of the emergence of active and devastating CMV disease, indicating that the virus had lain dormant until the patients’ immune systems were suppressed by this chemo drug.47,48
There’s a glimmer of hope on the horizon, however, the direct result of our understanding of the CMV/glioblastoma connection.
Antiviral Drug Quadruples Life Span!
Researchers at the internationally acclaimed Karolinska Institute in Sweden recently made medical headlines with their findings about the use of an antiviral drug quadrupling the lives of patients with glioblastomas.1 The drug, valganciclovir, is widely used in treatment of active CMV infection in immunocompromised patients.
Beginning with an animal model, the researchers found that they could reduce the growth of medulloblastomas (the main group of brain tumors to which glioblastomas belong) by 72% using a drug combination including valganciclovir to combat CMV infection.34
Next, they wanted to determine how effective valganciclovir would be as an add-on to chemotherapy. In a double-blind clinical trial, researchers gave valganciclovir to 42 glioblastoma patients already receiving standard chemotherapy.49 Although tumor sizes were smaller in treated than in non-treated patients, the difference was not statistically significant. There were no significant differences in survival over the 6 months of the study period.
However, that all changed when patients were allowed to continue taking the drug after the study phase. Analyses showed that patients taking valganciclovir for longer than 6 months had an overall survival of 24.1 months, compared with just 13.1 months (a typical survival time) in patients taking the drug for 0 to 6 months.49 By 4 years (an eternity for glioblastoma patients), 27.3% of long-term valciclovir patients survived, compared with just 5.9% of controls.
Encouraged by these results, the researchers immediately undertook another study, again providing valganciclovir as add-on to regular chemotherapy—but this time, extending the study period beyond the original 6-month time frame.1 Fifty patients were treated and compared with controls who received only standard care. In the authors’ own words, “The rate of survival of treated patients was remarkably high”—an understatement considering the facts. Take a look:
- At 2 years, 62% of all treated patients were still alive, compared with just 18% of controls with comparable cancers.1 Median overall survival was 25 months, vs. 13.5 months in controls (Figure 1a).
- Among those who received at least 6 months of valganciclovir, the 2-year survival rate was 70% and median overall survival was 30.1 months (Figure 1b).1
- And, among the 25 patients who received continuous valganciclovir treatment after the first 6 months, 90% of patients were alive at 2 years, and median overall survival was an incredible 56.4 months—that’s more than 4½ years, or a 4.2-fold increase over the 13.5 months in control patients.1 (Figure 1c)
In other words, even short-term treatment with valganciclovir nearly doubled overall survival time; medium-term therapy nearly tripled survival time, and long-term, continuous therapy more than quadrupled it.
These are compelling results. At this point, anyone with a diagnosis of glioblastoma and a desire to extend their lives as much as possible should demand therapy with oral valganciclovir, at 900 mg/day twice daily, followed by a maintenance dose of 450 mg twice daily, with adjustments as needed for impaired kidney function and bone marrow suppression.
What About The Rest Of Us?
As exciting as the results of this study were for those battling glioblastoma, valganciclovir is prohibitively expensive to use as a preventive drug. It can cost upwards of $50,000/year and has myriad side effects, including plummeting white blood cell counts.50
There are no known drugs or supplements that can prevent primary infection with CMV in humans. However, if you are CMV-positive (like so many Americans), there are a number of ways you can protect yourself against the effects of the virus, including protecting against immunosenescence, the immune aging that triggers CMV activation.
Fight CMV-Related Immunosenescence Naturally
Although no human data exist yet, there’s striking evidence that certain natural compounds can inhibit the replication and spread of CMV in animal and basic lab studies.
These include Urtica dioica (stinging nettle), garlic extract, Terminalia chebula (an Asian tree), ginger extracts, flavones from ginger-like Kaempferia parviflora, a variety of seaweed extracts, and oil from Nigella sativa (black cumin seed).51-58 Black cumin seed oil in particular was so effective in mice that, after 10 days of treatment, no virus was detected in treated animals, while it was readily detectable in control mice.55
Other nutrients can fight the CMV that may already be in your body by enhancing your immune system’s resources to fight CMV, as well as other infections that arise when immunosenescence sets in. These include the following:
- Probiotics and prebiotics, by balancing the intestinal microbial population, have powerful immune-stimulating properties.59,60 Studies show that probiotic/prebiotic therapy produces improvements in natural killer cell activity, activated T-lymphocytes (including “memory” cells responsible for recognizing old enemies), and cell signaling molecules called cytokines.61-64
- Elderly people are more likely to be deficient in zinc, a trace element absolutely required for normal immunity.65 Zinc supplementation fights immunosenescence by enhancing the appropriate immune response to stress in older humans and by increasing appropriate cytokine signaling to mobilize response to infection.66,67
- Sulfur-containing antioxidants such as N-acetylcysteine help replenish the body’s normal stores of natural antioxidants, which helps keep immune system cells fresh and vigorous. These supplements improve white blood cell function, increasing their ability to track and attack invaders, and increasing white cell proliferation in response to invasion.68 Aged mice fed a diet rich in N-acetylcysteine and thioproline for 5 weeks showed an improvement in all immune functions, with values becoming close to those of young adult animals.69
- Spirulina, a blue-green algae, increases the microbe-eating activity of white blood cells called macrophages, while stimulating antibody production and activating killer T-cells that destroy viruses and fungi.70-72
- Finally, the prescription drug metformin (which is in fact a natural derivative of the French lilac) has shown great promise in reducing immunosenescence and fighting CMV and CMV-related cancers.73 Metformin has shown surprisingly beneficial results in combination with standard treatments for breast cancer,74 and is now being closely investigated as an additional treatment for glioblastoma. Similar studies showed that metformin inhibits growth and migration of glioblastoma cells, a property that would reduce the tumor’s invasiveness in patients’ brains.75 Excitingly, metformin has now also been shown to promote differentiation of glioblastoma-initiating cells into non-cancer-producing cells in lab cultures.76